Supreme Court May REMOVE Democrat Judge After Chilling Discovery psss
Supreme Court May REMOVE Democrat Judge After Chilling Discovery
Allegations of Improper Political Contributions
1.1 Details of the JQC Complaint
In a formal petition filed earlier this month, the Judicial Qualifications Commission charged Judge Moon with violating Florida Rule of Judicial Administration 2.045 and the accompanying Code of Judicial Conduct. The core allegation is that, between 2022 and 2024, Judge Moon made multiple campaign contributions to:
Kamala Harris—then a candidate for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination.
Joe Biden—the eventual Democratic nominee and President of the United States.
ActBlue—a Democratic Party fundraising platform utilized by a wide array of progressive candidates and causes.
The JQC’s records indicate that these contributions totaled $2,115 and were made while Judge Moon was an active member of the Florida judiciary. Under Florida’s judicial canons, any direct financial support by a sitting judge of partisan political candidates or entities is strictly forbidden.1.2 The JQC’s Recommended Sanction
As part of a proposed resolution—subject to approval by the Florida Supreme Court—the JQC has suggested:
Public Censure: A formal reprimand to be entered in the official court record, made available to the public.
Monetary Penalty: A fine equaling the total amount of her prohibited contributions ($2,115).
The JQC stated that these sanctions, combined, “will be sufficient to deter similar misconduct by the respondent (Moon) in the future and will also serve as a reminder to future candidates for judicial office” of their duty to maintain the integrity of judicial elections.
2. Prior Misconduct Referrals
Judge Moon is already awaiting a separate decision by the Florida Supreme Court on earlier allegations of unprofessional conduct. Those charges stemmed from two incidents in January 2024:
Courtroom Solicitation: In open court, Judge Moon reminded attorney Michael Jones that he had not returned her after-hours phone call regarding her re-election campaign—comments that the JQC characterized as coercive given the inherent power dynamic between judge and attorney.
Ex Parte Contact: She directly contacted a therapist involved in a case before her court, a move the JQC argued violated the prohibition on ex parte communications, which safeguard fairness by preventing one party from gaining private access to the judge without the opposing side’s knowledge.
Earlier this year, the JQC recommended a public reprimand for those two incidents as well. Judge Moon has agreed to accept that sanction, though the final decision rests with the Florida Supreme Court.
The commission, which investigates judicial conduct, and judge Stefanie Moon reached an agreement to recommend that she face a public reprimand and pay a fine of $2,115, the amount of the political contributions. https://t.co/RAtJzGspO8
— NBC 6 South Florida (@nbc6) April 7, 2025
3. Florida’s Rules on Judicial Conduct and Political Activity
3.1 Rule of Judicial Administration 2.045
Florida Rule of Judicial Administration 2.045 governs judicial campaign practices. Key provisions include:
Prohibition on Partisan Activity: Judges and judicial candidates are prohibited from making contributions to or soliciting funds for any political party, political organization, or candidate.
Limits on Endorsements and Speeches: Judges may not publicly endorse or oppose candidates in partisan elections. They may attend nonpartisan forums but must avoid any action that could reasonably be viewed as political.
3.2 Code of Judicial Conduct Canon 7
The Code of Judicial Conduct sets forth principles to ensure judges remain nonpartisan and impartial. Canon 7 specifies that judges:
Shall not engage in political activity that would be inconsistent with the impartial performance of judicial duties.
Must refrain from activities that could create an appearance of impropriety or compromise public confidence in the judiciary.
Judge Moon’s donations—direct financial contributions to partisan candidates—are squarely barred under these provisions.
4. The Judicial Qualifications Commission: Oversight and Process
4.1 Composition and Mandate
The Florida Judicial Qualifications Commission is an independent state agency tasked with:
Investigating allegations of judicial misconduct or incapacity.
Holding formal hearings before JQC hearing panels.
Recommending disciplinary action—ranging from reprimand to removal—to the Florida Supreme Court.
The Commission consists of nine members: six appointed by the governor (including three lawyers and three nonlawyers) and three appointed by the Florida Supreme Court.
4.2 Investigative Procedures
Upon receipt of a complaint, the JQC:
Conducts preliminary fact-finding, requesting documents, campaign records, and sworn statements.
Decides whether to file formal charges. If charges are filed, the judge in question may negotiate a stipulated agreement—our current situation—or proceed to a public hearing.
Issues a recommendation to the Florida Supreme Court. Only the Court has authority to impose discipline, from reprimand up to removal from office.
Judge Moon has engaged with this process, indicating her willingness to accept sanction for both the campaign-contribution violations and the earlier misconduct claims.
5. Judge Stefanie Moon: Career and Community Involvement
5.1 Judicial and Legal Background
Education and Early Practice: Moon graduated from a major Florida law school and served as a state prosecutor before ascending to the circuit bench in 2015.
Circuit Court Assignments: As a Broward County Circuit Judge, she has presided over civil, family, and criminal matters, earning a reputation for efficiency and strong case-management skills.
5.2 Civic Engagement and Recognitions
Florida Supreme Court Historical Society: In 2024, Moon was nominated to a three-year term on the Society’s Board of Trustees, an honor that recognizes contributions to preserving Florida’s judicial history
Community Outreach: She has participated in judicial-education programs, speaking at local schools and bar associations about the rule of law and civic responsibility.
These accomplishments underscore the breadth of her service, even as the JQC process calls certain aspects of her conduct into question.
6. Comparative Analysis: Precedents and Expert Commentary
6.1 Similar Cases in Florida and Beyond
Judges nationwide have faced discipline for political activities:
Florida Precedent: In 2019, a Miami-Dade judge was publicly reprimanded for attending a fundraiser on behalf of a state legislative candidate—another clear violation of Rule 2.045.
James Has Released Thousands Of Criminal Aliens During Trump Term
New York state has released nearly 7,000 undocumented immigrants from local jails despite Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detainer requests, according to new data cited by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS)
DHS figures indicate that 6,947 individuals were released after being charged with or convicted of a range of offenses, including 29 homicides, 2,509 assaults, 199 burglaries, 305 robberies, 392 drug-related offenses, 300 weapons offenses and 207 sexual-offense cases involving predatory conduct.
Rep. Claudia Tenney, R-N.Y., discussed the developments during an appearance on Fox News with host Kayleigh McEnany on Saturday. Tenney also said New York Attorney General Letitia James is aware of the releases, alleging that James has pursued investigations into local sheriffs who cooperated with ICE.
According to the New York Post, the attorney general’s office has opened criminal inquiries into Oswego County Sheriff Don Hilton and the Nassau County Sheriff’s Office over alleged misconduct related to cooperation with federal immigration authorities.
“This is incomprehensible to me, people who immigration authorities want just let out in the streets of New York?” McEnany, who served as one of President Donald Trump’s press secretaries during his first term, said during the segment.
“Yeah, this is a sanctuary state, as you know, still is a sanctuary state run by the Democrats completely. Even the governor faces a veto proof majority in the legislature, and now we’re going to end up having, you know, a pro-sanctuary Mayor coming in the first of January,” Tenney said.
“But yeah, there are thousands, almost 7,000 people with these advanced criminal records like, you know, murder, you said, homicide, rape, extortion, you name it, just about every crime— child, sex crimes that are led into our state every single year, at least this last year,” she continued.
“And this is all done, and Letitia James, our Attorney General, was alerted. She doesn’t care. She even goes after and is trying to prosecute any of the local governments who want to cooperate with what is called the 287(g) program. That program allows local police to coordinate with ICE if we have dangerous criminal aliens within the confines of a county or a city,” the GOP lawmaker added.
“She is interfering with that. She’s actually prosecuting my home Sheriff for actually cooperating. And my district in upstate New York, New York 24, my entire northern border is the Canadian border, and we have had almost 90% of the people on the foreign terror watch list under Joe Biden were coming in across the northern border,” the lawmaker continued.
“So, it’s a very dangerous place and a very easy place for safe haven, especially with a sanctuary state like New York,” Tenney added.Meanwhile, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Director Todd Lyons has sent a letter to James urging the state to honor ICE detainer requests for the thousands of illegal aliens in state and local custody.
According to ICE, New York’s refusal to comply with detainers has led to the release of 6,947 individuals since Jan. 20. The agency says the offenses associated with those released include 29 homicides, 2,509 assaults, 199 burglaries, 305 robberies, 392 drug-related crimes, 300 weapons offenses, and 207 sexual predatory offenses.
“There are currently 7,113 aliens in the custody of a New York jurisdiction with an active detainer. The crimes of these aliens include 148 homicides, 717 assaults, 134 burglaries, 106 robberies, 235 dangerous drugs offenses, 152 weapons offenses, and 260 sexual predatory offenses,” says a Department of Homeland Security press release.
May you like
“Attorney General James and her fellow New York Sanctuary politicians are releasing murderers, terrorists, and sexual predators back into our neighborhoods and putting American lives at risk,” said Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin.
“We are calling on Letitia James to stop this dangerous derangement and commit to honoring the ICE arrest detainers of the more than 7,000 criminal illegal aliens in New York’s custody. It is common sense. Criminal illegal aliens should not be released back onto our streets to terrorize more innocent Americans,” McLaughlin added.
